of my ministry, to advocate at different levels for the global abolition. Legally, criminals are to be "innocent until proven guilty but in reality they are often "guilty until proven innocent". How would Kant calculate the equality of crime and retribution if the wrong person is injudiciously put to death while the actual killer goes free? . As MacKinnon states when discussing Natural Law Theory, " the innate drive toward living is a good in itself" (133). However, if a crime deserves equal punishment, then why do we not rape the rapist or burn the arsonist? Research Papers 1159 words (3.3 pages) - Argument Against the Death Penalty Life is sacred. The convicted is sentence to death because of the heinous crimes they have committed by the legal process.
Some would argue that the execution of a murderer is in the self-defense of society itself. Garrett was in fact, a mentally ill man who suffered severe childhood trauma, significant brain damage and multiple personality disorder. This is something that has been taught by the Roman Catholic Church for years.
The eighth amendment protects people from excessive bail, excessive fines imposed, or cruel and unusual punishments. This is not to argue that certain actions do not morally require punishment, but simply to argue that the death penalty itself is an inappropriate form of punishment because of the way that it devalues life itself. The executive director of Death Penalty Information Center, which doesnt take a side in the debate, told the Guardian that his question was what impact the popes words might have. Do we treat individual lives and liberty so lightly that we can tolerate having innocents killed or caged by the state in our name? Many countries also have the death penalty for sexual crimes such as rape, incest and adultery.
In 1988 a survey was conducted for the UN to determine the relation between the death penalty and homicide rates.
This was then updated in 1996.
That is why, even if every other argument against it were valid, justice alone demands that we keep the death penalty.
For it is the only just and compassionate response to murder.